Phase 3: independent elemental tender estimate
What we asked: "Price the tender drawings like a QS would, before the builders' prices come back."
What it produced:
- Measured quantities from the drawing schedules: floor areas (273.4 m² total, 125.6 m² of it new extension), foundations, steel, slabs, wall areas, roofs, glazing, finishes, M&E and drainage.
- An elemental bill in 13 elements (preliminaries and PSCS through to external works), each with low, mid and high rates and the basis for each rate.
- The PC sums as issued, with notes on which ones looked too low.
- OH&P and VAT shown separately; fees and contingency kept outside the tender figure.
- A ranked risk list: floor areas not matching the brief, steel and temporary works as the biggest swing item, a new slab in the existing house, wastewater testing, a PC sum that looked low, and areas scaled rather than dimensioned.
Figures: [AWAITING JAMES APPROVAL]. We're not publishing the project's estimate figures. The method is explained in How to tender a renovation.
How we checked it: we compared the rates with published cost guidance (SCSI), cross-checked areas against the drawing schedules, and flagged every assumed quantity.